Comparison

GPS tracker or school transport app? What each one tells you.

A GPS tracker tells a vehicle owner where the vehicle is. A school transport app tells a school and its parents where each child is, and who had them at every step. They are built for different questions. Here is a fair look at both, so you can choose what your school needs.

Side by side

The short version

Trackers vary by make and plan. This compares what each kind of product is generally built to do.

QuestionGPS trackerSchool transport app
What it followsThe vehicle, all dayThe trip, and each child on it
What you installA device fitted in the vehicle, usually with its own SIM or subscriptionAn app on the driver's Android phone
Knows who is aboardNoYes: each child's card is scanned on and each drop confirmed
Who sees the positionWhoever holds the tracker login, usually the ownerThe school, and each parent only while their own child is riding
Messages to parentsNot usuallyBoarded, dropped, about five minutes away, and nobody at the door
Engine, fuel and speed dataOftenNo
When the driver's phone is offKeeps reportingStops reporting, and the school sees the last position marked as old
Records for the schoolA history of where the vehicle wentWho boarded, was dropped and was handed over, with times
directions_car

When a tracker is the better fit

You own vehicles and want to know where they are at night, how they are driven, how much fuel they use, or to help recover one that is stolen. A hard-wired tracker keeps reporting whether or not anyone opens an app, and that is its strength.

family_restroom

When a school transport app is the better fit

You want to know that each child got on, got off at the right place, and was handed to the right person. Parents want to be told without phoning the school. A tracker cannot answer those questions, because it does not know who is in the vehicle.

A boarded message in the parent app
What a school transport app adds

The child, not just the vehicle

In StudentAid, the van's position is one part of a record that follows each child through the day.

  • checkA QR card scanned as each child boards, which works with no signal
  • checkA drop confirmed at each stop, which is what tells the parent
  • checkA recorded wait when nobody comes to the door
  • checkA hand-over at the school gate that the driver confirms
  • checkA daily vehicle check before the first run
  • checkA pickup log and reports the school can show an inspector or a parent

Where a phone-based app falls short

To be fair to trackers, this is what a phone cannot do as well.

  • checkIt reports only while a trip is running and the driver's phone is on and charged
  • checkIt knows nothing about the vehicle itself: no engine, fuel or speed data
  • checkIt depends on the driver starting the trip, which is why the school sees any trip that has not started

If those matter to you, keep a tracker for the vehicle and use a school transport app for the children. They do not get in each other's way. Read more about school van tracking with StudentAid.

Tracker or app: questions

Does StudentAid connect to a tracker we already have?

No. StudentAid takes the van's position from the driver's phone during a trip. A tracker you already have keeps working on its own.

Is a phone's GPS good enough for school vans?

For showing a parent where the van is and when it is near, yes. When the app has not had a new position for a while, it shows the old one as old rather than guessing.

What if the driver forgets to start the trip?

The school sees a trip that has not started on its screen, and parents see no van. That is the honest gap in a phone-based app, and the reason the start is one tap.

Can we use both?

Yes. They answer different questions. Many vehicle owners keep a tracker for the vehicle, and the school uses a transport app for the children.

See what your vans would look like

We show you a real run on your own routes, with your own drivers' phones.